You are referring to some use cases I'm totally unaware of. If it is required, why not pick a tool that can already do it, there are multiple available, including ones that are not (necessarily) subscription-based (and not developed by Adobe, if that is important). I suppose IDML export is more a kind of a one-off tool for the purpose of providing a client with an editable document they wished to have (and many clients do nowadays, in addition to getting a production file as a PDF). But seriously, being afraid of competition and someone developing interchange support for Adobe created things is not the first thing that comes in mind when visiting and seeing the sheer amount of open and free as per version targeted documentation, SDKs and tools available for anyone interested.Įven with full IDML export support, true co-operation between diverse professionals already happens in the cloud and using common tools. If you mean that the documentation is "hidden" amongst 81,960 files within the ID Plug-in SDK so that a possible competitor gets exhausted and will give up already when extracting the about 3.5GB package (a task that takes about an hour), then perhaps so. It should mean that they wouldn't be too happy, if IDML export from Publisher does happen. If only it could connect with the old "industry standard"…Īdobe has already hidden the IDML specs document. This is the perfect scenario for something like the Affinity Suite. In my part of the world (generally called the Occident or the West) the jobs landscape is quickly changing from a relation between a company and its employees, and one where a company hires freelancers. I guess this is a typical situation: an army of freelancers that would feel at home with Publisher, but are forced by a top-manager to use the "industry standard" solution. I could simply convince them to switch to Publisher, if it wasn't for the fact that they are higher in hierarchy than me. However, there is someone who wants InDesign files. The page layout program can be used by the most scrupulous ones to fix some details that may go lost in the conversion. These want an INDD or IDML file, or an XML file if available, whatever the originating program. My current workflow requires exchange between my InDesign files and the translators' CAT programs (not the same: each one uses a different one…). I often receive and send DOCX files, just to discover that the originals have been made with Apple Pages or LibreOffice. For example, in my career I've been using FreeHand and Illustrator, while my colleagues have been using Illustrator or CorelDRAW (apparently, the preferred drawing tool for technical designers). In my experience, this is not a universal truth. It has been objected that a team must use the same tool. Even if all the features I need are implemented in Publisher, not being able to interconnect with InDesign will exclude it from my workflow. I've expressed my desire for IDML export elsewhere, but I'll reiterate here. It has been asked before, I know, but I could not find any definite answer to your company policy in this regard. afpub formats, it is feature rich enough to work as a common ground. If roundtripping would be possible, the matter would be a very different one.Įven if IDML might not be fully feature complete compared to the. In my book, the Affinity suite in the meantime is on par or superior to the equivalent Adobe programs (disregarded any cloud AI features etc.), but it's super hard to convince our office superiors to switch. It would be desirable to leave the choice to the user, of course. That often results in the decision to not use Publisher at all. Not being able to export from Publisher to InDesign means the whole team might be forced to use the Affinity suite, if just one member decides to use Publisher. It's great to be able to import from InDesign, but as of now it's a one way ticked. I assume you are aware why this is important in a mixed team with Adobe products. Can we get an official statement if the IDML (InDesign markup language) file format will ever be supported for export from Publisher?
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |